The most common step in creating software is building it. Usually this means running make or equivalent and waiting. This step is so universal that most people don’t even think about it actively. If one were to see what the computer is doing during build, one would see compiler processes taking 100% of the machine’s CPUs. Thus the system is working as fast as it possibly can.
Some people working on Chromium doubted this and built their own replacement of Make called Ninja. It is basically the same as Make: you specify a list of dependencies and then tell it to build something. Since Make is one of the most used applications in the world and has been under development since the 70s, surely it is as fast as it can possibly be done.
Well, let’s find out. Chromium uses a build system called Gyp that generates makefiles. Chromium devs have created a Ninja backend for Gyp. This makes comparing the two extremely easy.
Compiling Chromium from scratch on a dual core desktop machine with makefiles takes around 90 minutes. Ninja builds it in less than an hour. A quad core machine builds Chromium in ~70 minutes. Ninja takes ~40 minutes. Running make on a tree with no changes at all takes 3 minutes. Ninja takes 3 seconds.
So not only is Ninja faster than Make, it is faster by a huge margin and especially on the use case that matters for the average developer: small incremental changes.
What can we learn from this?
There is an old (and very wise) saying that you should never optimize before you measure. In this case the measurement seemed to indicate that nothing was to be done: CPU load was already maximized by the compiler processes. But sometimes your tools give you misleading data. Sometimes they lie to you. Sometimes the “common knowledge” of the entire development community is wrong. Sometimes you just have to do the stupid, irrational, waste-of-time -thingie.
This is called progress.
PS I made quick-n-dirty packages of a Ninja git checkout from a few days ago and put them in my PPA. Feel free to try them out. There is also an experimental CMake backend for Ninja so anyone with a CMake project can easily try what kind of a speedup they would get.Read more